The decline of the player-manager...
The decline of the player-manager...
Something I mentioned in a different thread was the 'disappearance' of the player-manager. They just don't seem very common any more. They were not an unusual occurrence in the lower divisions, in the 70s, 80s, 90s and by the late 80s, it became - thanks to Kenny Dalglish - fashionable for top clubs to even consider having one.
But I struggle to think of many now, other than James Beattie, perhaps.
Torquay have had the following player-managers...
Crad Evans
Percy Mackrill
(although with these two, I think teams were selected by committee)
Eric Webber
Lew Chatterley (caretaker)
Mike Green
Bruce Rioch (possibly one of my all-time heroes at TUFC - I was devastated when he left and his subsequent managerial career showed what we missed out on)
David Webb (although not officially, just the team were so short of players he had to, then scored the winner against Crewe, believed his own hype and picked himself for a few more games)
John Sims (not sure if he played as manager but was player-coach when appointed)
Wes Saunders (caretaker)
Don O'Riordan (I remember his 87th minute winning goal at St James Park)
...and that is it...no player-manager since October 1995 and a 1-8 home defeat to Scunny.
In these cash-strapped times, I would have thought it would have been an increasingly attractive option for clubs to consider, if they can find the right manager.
It used to be that top players would move down the leagues to player-manage small clubs. I remember us being linked with Emlyn Hughes around 81/82 but he went to Rotherham and I think he got them promoted. Some like Alan Ball, started badly but later got decent careers in management (somehow) and also Gerry Francis, who was terrible at Exeter but later managed Tottenham.
But I struggle to think of many now, other than James Beattie, perhaps.
Torquay have had the following player-managers...
Crad Evans
Percy Mackrill
(although with these two, I think teams were selected by committee)
Eric Webber
Lew Chatterley (caretaker)
Mike Green
Bruce Rioch (possibly one of my all-time heroes at TUFC - I was devastated when he left and his subsequent managerial career showed what we missed out on)
David Webb (although not officially, just the team were so short of players he had to, then scored the winner against Crewe, believed his own hype and picked himself for a few more games)
John Sims (not sure if he played as manager but was player-coach when appointed)
Wes Saunders (caretaker)
Don O'Riordan (I remember his 87th minute winning goal at St James Park)
...and that is it...no player-manager since October 1995 and a 1-8 home defeat to Scunny.
In these cash-strapped times, I would have thought it would have been an increasingly attractive option for clubs to consider, if they can find the right manager.
It used to be that top players would move down the leagues to player-manage small clubs. I remember us being linked with Emlyn Hughes around 81/82 but he went to Rotherham and I think he got them promoted. Some like Alan Ball, started badly but later got decent careers in management (somehow) and also Gerry Francis, who was terrible at Exeter but later managed Tottenham.
-
- Top Scorer
- Posts: 1367
- Joined: 12 Sep 2010, 11:06
- Location: Traverse City, Michigan
Edgar Davids
-
- Legend
- Posts: 7759
- Joined: 02 May 2018, 19:20
- Favourite player: You'll find out ;-)
Ainsworth at Wycombe was a PM last season.
The last person I can remember being signed as a PM was Ginaluca Vialli (that may well be spelt incorrectly) at Chelsea.
Matt.
The last person I can remember being signed as a PM was Ginaluca Vialli (that may well be spelt incorrectly) at Chelsea.
Matt.
J5 said, "ferrarilover is 100% correct"
...and they were following a template of their own, with Hoddle, Guillit, then Vialli (I think, in that order)ferrarilover wrote:Ainsworth at Wycombe was a PM last season.
The last person I can remember being signed as a PM was Ginaluca Vialli (that may well be spelt incorrectly) at Chelsea.
Matt.
Forgot about Davids and Ainsworth.
-
- Legend
- Posts: 7759
- Joined: 02 May 2018, 19:20
- Favourite player: You'll find out ;-)
Oh yeah, Ruud Guillit, I'd forgotten about him. Great player, not sure about his management though.
Matt.
Matt.
J5 said, "ferrarilover is 100% correct"
-
- Country Captain
- Posts: 3553
- Joined: 18 Sep 2010, 17:29
- Favourite player: ROBIN STUBBS
- Location: Gloucester
I think you will find that Gerry Francis managed Bristol Rovers and was hugely successful before being poached to manage QPR.hector wrote:Something I mentioned in a different thread was the 'disappearance' of the player-manager. They just don't seem very common any more. They were not an unusual occurrence in the lower divisions, in the 70s, 80s, 90s and by the late 80s, it became - thanks to Kenny Dalglish - fashionable for top clubs to even consider having one.
But I struggle to think of many now, other than James Beattie, perhaps.
Torquay have had the following player-managers...
Crad Evans
Percy Mackrill
(although with these two, I think teams were selected by committee)
Eric Webber
Lew Chatterley (caretaker)
Mike Green
Bruce Rioch (possibly one of my all-time heroes at TUFC - I was devastated when he left and his subsequent managerial career showed what we missed out on)
David Webb (although not officially, just the team were so short of players he had to, then scored the winner against Crewe, believed his own hype and picked himself for a few more games)
John Sims (not sure if he played as manager but was player-coach when appointed)
Wes Saunders (caretaker)
Don O'Riordan (I remember his 87th minute winning goal at St James Park)
...and that is it...no player-manager since October 1995 and a 1-8 home defeat to Scunny.
In these cash-strapped times, I would have thought it would have been an increasingly attractive option for clubs to consider, if they can find the right manager.
It used to be that top players would move down the leagues to player-manage small clubs. I remember us being linked with Emlyn Hughes around 81/82 but he went to Rotherham and I think he got them promoted. Some like Alan Ball, started badly but later got decent careers in management (somehow) and also Gerry Francis, who was terrible at Exeter but later managed Tottenham.
Always Look on the bright side of life
Check out my poems topic... http://www.torquayfans.com/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=4843
Check out my poems topic... http://www.torquayfans.com/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=4843
Chris Brass was a player-manager at York.
Was Kevin Hodges registered as a player during his first season as manager? I thought he might have been an unused sub a couple of times when we were desperate. And of course he had player-coaches with him, Garry Nelson and Steve McCall.
Was Kevin Hodges registered as a player during his first season as manager? I thought he might have been an unused sub a couple of times when we were desperate. And of course he had player-coaches with him, Garry Nelson and Steve McCall.
-
- First Regular
- Posts: 439
- Joined: 23 Apr 2013, 09:31
- Favourite player: Manse
Not as a player manager though Glos.Glostergull wrote:I think you will find that Gerry Francis managed Bristol Rovers and was hugely successful before being poached to manage QPR.
The players at PL/Championship level dont need to prolong their careers nowadays by dropping down the divisions into player/manager jobs to top up their earnings.
Apathy Rules...............it's ok though, nobody's that fussed about it........
-
- Plays for Country
- Posts: 2168
- Joined: 07 Oct 2013, 17:48
- Favourite player: Jake Andrews
- Location: Preston Sands
I've been watching your spelling teacher!ferrarilover wrote:Ainsworth at Wycombe was a PM last season.
The last person I can remember being signed as a PM was Ginaluca Vialli (that may well be spelt incorrectly) at Chelsea.
Matt.
-
- Legend
- Posts: 7759
- Joined: 02 May 2018, 19:20
- Favourite player: You'll find out ;-)
I haven't got a spelling teacher.
Matt.
Matt.
J5 said, "ferrarilover is 100% correct"
I think, actually, you will find Gerry Francis started his managerial career at Exeter City around 1983, some time before he was at Bristol Rovers. He lasted one season, after replacing Brian Godfrey, and Exeter were relegated, finishing rock bottom. Francis went back to playing afterwards and was a player at Bristol Rovers when he got the job there.Glostergull wrote: I think you will find that Gerry Francis managed Bristol Rovers and was hugely successful before being poached to manage QPR.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Hereford Gull66 and 19 guests