Page 3 of 8

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 23 Nov 2010, 23:35
by Dave
Yellow4life wrote:It does seem that a club has today bid a three figure sum and I can now see him going.

Trouble is- who will score the goals? Will zebroski go up top? Is this kee's chance to prove himself or are we going to loan someone in?

One of these has to happen otherwise I can't see us scoring!!
:|

:goal:
A three figure wow,was hoping for more than £999 for benners :-D ,maybe a 6 figure sum :)

and whilst i understand where your coming from,i am sure the team will still score goals,bucks will have something lined up.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 23 Nov 2010, 23:36
by Fletch
Yellow4life wrote:It does seem that a club has today bid a three figure sum and I can now see him going. :goal:
I would like to think we would get in excess of £999 for him :lol: :lol:

edit: beat me to it :)

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 09:22
by HRG
This today http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/footbal ... 222075.stm
Is Bucks giving us false hope? Doesn't sound like a deal is done and dusted. Or perhaps it's an attempt to get a better deal. So many possibilities.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 10:35
by CP Gull
The Herald today confirms the rumoured interest of both Southend and as we know Dagenham, but DT suggests that Swindon Town are interested in him as well and they may well make a move for him, particularly if Charlie Austin moves on. The Herald speculates that we are looking for a figure of around £75k for him and certainly you would expect a club like Swindon to be able to afford to splash that sort of cash, whether they sell Austin, or not.

Personally, I would feel a lot happier for the club and the player if it was Swindon, as selling to a club in our own division (Southend) would leave a bit of a bitter taste and as far as the player is concerned a move to the likes of Dagenham is hardly progression, given that they may well be back in League 2 next season and who knows we could even replace them in League One!

Oh well, I guess we will find out one way or the other in the next 24 hours (and a bit) what's happening.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 11:22
by Yellow4life
75k is all well and good but isn't it worth holding out until January to make a deal; possibly getting more money? If he leaves it'll only be for a loan anyway until January.

It will also suit us as we have time to find a replacement.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 11:26
by Fletch
CP Gull wrote:The Herald today confirms the rumoured interest of both Southend and as we know Dagenham, but DT suggests that Swindon Town are interested in him as well and they may well make a move for him
Not too suprised at Swindon being interested. They're not finding it easy this season with Paynter having left without really replacing him :goal:

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 11:46
by numpte
If its Swindon, I hope its at least six figures and sell on as they turned down 600k in the summer for him.

Figures of £40k. Why bovver?

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 12:00
by Fonda
Less than 6 figures at this stage would be pointless. For the reasons i suggested previously.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:39
by chippygull
numpte wrote:If its Swindon, I hope its at least six figures and sell on as they turned down 600k in the summer for him.

Figures of £40k. Why bovver?

WHAT? Who turned down 600k for who?

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:42
by Plymouth Gull
£600k for Austin, I'd assume.

As said, Swindon looks most likely, and Yellow4life; Any move now would be a loan, with a permanent agreed for January. So basically they're buying him.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:43
by CraigUnder
chippygull wrote:
WHAT? Who turned down 600k for who?
i believe he is on about charlie austin?

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 13:55
by chippygull
Phew!

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 14:07
by ferrarilover
So, Swindon are replacing a £700,000 player (for example) with a £70,000 player. They must see an awful lot of room for improvement in Benyon. Good luck to the lad, he's v frustrating sometimes, but I'm sure, with the right coaching and a decent pair of boots, he'll be up there with the best.

Have TUFC ever been associated with a £1,000,000 player before?

Matt.

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 15:06
by bixieupnorth
a bidding war would be nice!! i'd let him go for anything above £75k plus a decent sell on clause

i think there are much better all round strikers about than him and if we have to get shot then its best to do it now before he decides to wait and see out his contract

Re: Bid for Benyon rejected!

Posted: 24 Nov 2010, 15:10
by numpte
Yes Austin, although they now rate him in the £2m category - Go to Thisisswindon.co.uk and follow the STFC links as Austin is on there this week claiming he wants to play higher up.

Nothing less than £100k for me for Benners then.