Page 7 of 12

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 17:08
by Gulls10
I think there is a lot of hysterical nonsense on this thread so far. It is an administration error by someone. It is embarrassing but it happens and when it does it is in the full glare of media and fans.

The likely punishment is likely to be a slap on the wrist and we should not lose any points as we did not gain any from the mistake.

Hopefully it leads to a tighening of procedure as imagine it had happened on Saturday's game, we had won and lost a tie v man Utd. That would have been shambolic.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 17:19
by ferrarilover
I'm not normally one for newbies throwing phrases like the one in Gulls10's post above, but it doesn't stop him being right.
Just be cool everybody. We aren't in anywhere near as much trouble as we might think, of this I am pretty sure.

It's not like we had any reputation to besmirch, it seems we are even less popular with the popular media than Chelsea under Mourinho.

Matt.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 17:24
by Fletch
How long do you have to be registered on here before throwing phrases around then Matt ?? :) :)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 17:31
by Plymouth Gull
Before 12 noon, Fletch.

;-)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 17:54
by ferrarilover
Fletch wrote:How long do you have to be registered on here before throwing phrases around then Matt ?? :) :)

Longer than you, back in your box. :)

Matt.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:04
by Dave_Pougher
WOW hang on a minute everybody !

You think this is baD NEWS ?

I ONLY GOT 4 POINTS ON THE PREDICTION LEAGUE THIS WEEK !

He without sin and all that !

Worse things have happened and I'm sure even worse things will happen in the future.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:08
by Fletch
Dave_Pougher wrote:WOW hang on a minute everybody !

You think this is baD NEWS ?

I ONLY GOT 4 POINTS ON THE PREDICTION LEAGUE THIS WEEK !

He without sin and all that !

Worse things have happened and I'm sure even worse things will happen in the future.
Did you register all your selections in time? :) :)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:27
by Scott Brehaut
ferrarilover wrote: I know it's old news now, but does anyone have a twitter username for the club sec?

Matt.
http://x.com/AnnMS4

That will be one vote for member of the month please....... ;-)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:38
by Southampton Gull
Gulls10 wrote:I think there is a lot of hysterical nonsense on this thread so far. It is an administration error by someone. It is embarrassing but it happens and when it does it is in the full glare of media and fans.

The likely punishment is likely to be a slap on the wrist and we should not lose any points as we did not gain any from the mistake.

Hopefully it leads to a tighening of procedure as imagine it had happened on Saturday's game, we had won and lost a tie v man Utd. That would have been shambolic.

It might seem hysterical nonsense to you, but maybe I can alert you to some facts.

This same person has made two similar errors in the recent past. Firstly Jake Thomson, and also Michael Poke, so that makes it three errors and now we have to explain this to the Football League. Somehow I think we might be getting a kick up the arse rather than a slap on the wrist ;-)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:50
by Trojan 67
In looking direct at the obvious, why is it frequently overlooked ?

Next question.

Why, when being aware an ineligible player was on the field of play, was he not immediately withdrawn ?

I wonder if this question will be asked by the FA.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:54
by Southampton Gull
Trojan 67 wrote:In looking direct at the obvious, why is it frequently overlooked ?

Next question.

Why, when being aware an ineligible player was on the field of play, was he not immediately withdrawn ?

I wonder if this question will be asked by the FA.
It's too late, once the game starts it really doesn't matter.

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:54
by Fletch
Trojan 67 wrote:In looking direct at the obvious, why is it frequently overlooked ?

Next question.
Why, when being aware an ineligible player was on the field of play, was he not immediately withdrawn ?
I wonder if this question will be asked by the FA.
Im guessing that as soon as he sets foot on the pitch, the regulation is broken (or even being on the team sheet handed to the ref). Withdrawing him would not be likely to cut any ice with the FL

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 18:59
by CraigUnder
whats the worst that could happen? hefty fine? point deductions? .. oh and with all of this, is he eligible to play on saturday?

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 19:02
by Fletch
tufcgull wrote:whats the worst that could happen? hefty fine? point deductions? .. oh and with all of this, is he eligible to play on saturday?
Depends on the size / I think so / I dont think so / Yes :) :)

Re: Player ineligible to play last night - CONFIRMED

Posted: 02 Feb 2011, 19:23
by Trojan 67
Southampton Gull wrote: It's too late, once the game starts it really doesn't matter.
If the action had been taken, the FA may/might see it as an act of contrition/mitigating factor in righting a wrong although it is after the fact.

Does that make sense ? :rofl: